Excommunicated Priest Leads SOA Watch “Occupy Fort Benning” Protest

By Alexander McKay   
November 24, 2011
Rally for Troops at Fort Benning
Rally for the troops.
For the fifth year TFP Student Action volunteers went to Fort Benning, Georgia.  The purpose of the trip was twofold:  To rally support for our troops and oppose the leftist SOA Watch protest called “Occupy Fort Benning.”

Rally for the Troops

On Friday morning, November 18, we kicked off our first rally for the troops on Broadway, downtown Columbus. With a banner inscribed with “God bless our troops!” and signs encouraging passing cars to “Honk for our brave troops,” we received numerous and positive responses.   The shouts of joy, thumbs up and waves were constant; the honks from trucks deafening.

The same ardor was seen the following day when we were stationed near the protest site on Fort Benning Road.  Honks were especially noisy when groups of hippie protesters passed by.  Here, we displayed another banner:  “No one can be at the same time a good Catholic and a true Socialist." – Pope Pius XI.

TFP Student Action rally for troops at Fort Benning
Passing vehicles honked their support for the troops with thunderous gusto.
The Pope’s phrase caused some controversy.  And our rally site rapidly became the scene of heated debates, ranging from the SOA Watch to morality, the Church’s teaching on just war, and the role of harmonic inequality.

A U. S. Army Major approached with his son.  “I live nearby and I just had to stop and say thank you for doing this.”  Moments later, an Army wife, visibly upset by the protesters, asked if she could borrow one of our “God Bless Fort Benning” signs.  After about an hour, she returned to tell us that she had walked deep into the protest, holding the sign up high.  Several protesters confronted her.  Others said: “We support the troops.” But she replied: “Why won’t you say that on the loudspeaker?”  

Excommunicated Priest Leads a Shrinking Protest

Fr. Roy Bourgeois SOA Watch
Excommunicated priest,
Roy Bourgeois.
The excommunicated priest who leads the annual SOA Watch protest, Roy Bourgeois, is attracting a dwindling mix of dissident Catholics, aging nuns, socialists, communists, anarchists, and confused college students.  

Protest vendors exhibiting books about Stalin, Marx, Che Guevara and Fidel Castro saw sales plummet this year, according to reports.   Despite the “occupy” claim of representing 99% of America, few showed up.   After all, how many Americans really want bumper stickers and patches with offensive inscriptions such as “F*** patriotism,” “Lesbian,” and “Feminist”?  How many Americans want Che Guevara T-shirts?  Not even 0.99%.

Capt. J. D. Hawk of the Columbus Police Department estimated the presence of 3,210 protesters, a 32% decrease from last year’s attendance.   Considering the fact that SOA Watch boasted having 22,000 protesters in 2006, the drop in numbers is considerable.  

In the National Catholic Reporter, Bourgeois explains why the protest is failing:  “What I’ve heard the last couple of years, some people have said, 'My bones can't take it anymore.' This is our 22nd year, and if you started here 20 years ago and you were 60, you’re now 80.”

SOA Watch counter-protested by TFP Student Action
This "Catholic" leftist protester holding the rainbow flag ranted against the Church
because the twelve Apostles were men.
What We Saw Inside the Protest

The most shocking aspect of the protest was the presence of many nuns, sporting t-shirts with the name of their order, which was the only way to identify them as consecrated religious.  These aging nuns held signs or operated booths supporting women’s ordination and other dissident causes.    

The booth of the Progressive Catholic Coalition, for example, was highly disturbing.  A wicker basket with communion wafers rested on the table near the following sign:  “Guerrilla Communion – Take one and break it with someone.”

Other groups supported illegal immigration or displayed posters to “free Bradley Manning,” the suspect traitor responsible for Wikileaks.

Just as Fr. Bourgeois began his talk on stage, we entered the protest perimeter and peacefully shared the TFP flyer with hundreds of people: Who Do the “Occupy Fort Benning” Protesters Represent? -- Unmasking the 0.99%. The flyer sparked discussions.  Perplexed college students even questioned the motives behind the protest.  

It was great.  Disagreements broke out among the protesters themselves.
“We need a socialist society with total equality,” insisted one protester.
“No!”a fellow protester disagreed, “We need to elect officials and that would be hierarchical.”
“No,” added a third, “the community will rule…”

SOA Watch debate
TFP Student Action volunteers talk to SOA Watch protesters about the importance
of morality as well as the dangers of socialism and anarchy.

Subscribe to our weekly TFP newsletter  for free.


An older pacifist protester denied the right of self-defense. “There is no authority.  If a criminal broke into my home, I wouldn’t call the police because the police use force.  I would rather die.”  One gray-haired feminist woman who claimed to be Catholic frantically complained how TFP volunteers were “all young.”  Donning a rainbow flag around her shoulders, she screamed: “Jesus was not God.  We shouldn’t follow the Church because it was founded by men.”

While the protester complained about our being “all young,” a shop owner near the intersection was delighted by the fact.  “It’s nice to see young men with their heads screwed on correctly,” he said.

May God continue to bless Fort Benning, our troops, and our nation.


If you’d like to support the troops with us next year at Fort Benning, contact us here.

 

TFP on WTVM Channel 9:



Related:
 

Comments  

 
+19 # lorraine schwartz 2011-11-24 19:01
Thank you brave and courageous students for standing up for our country and our church. I would definitely delete the word father as he is no longer a priest that is reserved and revered by the people. He is just a guy
Thank you and I look up to you.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+19 # lorraine schwartz 2011-11-24 19:04
Thank you young men and women who courageously take a stand for what is right. You represent most of us. Delete the word Father, as he is no longer a priest in good standing. the word Father is reserved for those who are preaching and teaching according to the Holy Father. The so called nuns are another story.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+20 # Kevin Williams 2011-11-29 13:32
I broke out laughing joyfully when I read of the shop owners response: "It nice to see men with their heads screwed on correctly"
I am overjoyed at the fact that many young people are pro life and pro God. The tide is turning! Hallelujah!
I must confess I feel a little left out though. I am considering starting a movement "Old geezers for God and for Life" :-)
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
-19 # Richard C 2011-11-29 13:43
If TFP supports evils such as SOA then they are as bad as the atheist/socialist protestors.
If I didn't have strong Catholic values I would probably be a socialist
If I didn't have strong social justice values I would possibly be fascist.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+26 # Cpt Gene Leone Ret. 2011-11-29 13:54
I'm glad he was defrocked. By definition, communism and Christianity are mutually exclusive. It saddens and sickens me to see these marxists protesting those who sign a blank check payable on demand with their very life in defense of them. As for the people holding the “rainbow” banner, they don’t realize they are nothing more than what lenin (lcit) called “useful idiots”. Do they really believe in a marxist society “gays” are accepted with open arms? I don’t THINK so! As for the defrocked priest, he’d do well to remember Matt. 18:6, “But whoever shall offend one of these little ones which believe in me, it were better for him that a millstone were hanged about his neck, and that he were drowned in the depth of the sea.” (AKJV)
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+11 # Trevor 2011-11-30 12:25
Well done boys, well done. Keep up the good fight until every heart is converted to the Lord.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+13 # Patricia 2011-11-30 12:28
This is very frightening. God bless you for your witness to Holy Mother Church and her truth. May the Archangels protect you as you go. I too support and pray for our troops. I have to say, I don't like our men and women in the Middle East fighting for something that is unclear. I also don't trust the leadership of our country or military to make the right decisions anymore. I hope and pray this changes.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
-3 # Jeannon Kralj 2011-11-30 12:29
Can't say I am fully FOR either side in this dialectical display.

You have socialist Catholics of the communist variety vying against socialist Catholics of the NAZI (National Socialists - fascist) kind.

There are dark forces behind the scenes loving what they have engineered here.

Each should demonstrate separately for the love Christ, to uplift the Savior, to risk being arrested and jailed for the Christ. Demonstrate not against this evil City of Man, but for the City of God.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+11 # Donald Garcia 2011-11-30 12:40
You guys are great!! I wonder why the lady with the peace flag looked so not at peace with what your group does!! here face speaks volumes about how angry an unhappy "socialists" are.
Pax et Bonum
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
-2 # Barbara Anna 2011-11-30 12:58
Quoting Richard C:
If TFP supports evils such as SOA then they are as bad as the atheist/socialist protestors.
If I didn't have strong Catholic values I would probably be a socialist
If I didn't have strong social justice values I would possibly be fascist.

Richard C., did you read this article?
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
-1 # TFWLOL 2011-11-30 13:07
YQuoting Barbara Anna:
Quoting Richard C:
If TFP supports evils such as SOA then they are as bad as the atheist/socialist protestors.
If I didn't have strong Catholic values I would probably be a socialist
If I didn't have strong social justice values I would possibly be fascist.

Richard C., did you read this article?

Yeah. IKR?
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+10 # steve 2011-11-30 13:10
I would add that it is impossible to be a good Catholic (pro-life and pro-heterosexual marriage) and vote Democrat. In the 2008 election, amazingly 25-28% of voters who identified as "evangelical Christians" still voted for the pro-abortion, pro-homosexual marriage candidate. People seem to forget their religious beliefs when they go into the voting booth.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # Elizabeth Gonzalez 2011-11-30 13:36
Quoting lorraine schwartz:
Thank you young men and women who courageously take a stand for what is right. You represent most of us. Delete the word Father, as he is no longer a priest in good standing. the word Father is reserved for those who are preaching and teaching according to the Holy Father. The so called nuns are another story.

I agree. But I'm British so the story is not one I fully understand. One thing I'm afraid I cannot agree with is the story is the banner by Pope Piux XI. I know the Pope was talking about Communism and I am completely against that but I am a commited Catholic but also left wing. There are all shades of socialism. Right now there is a strike happening in the UK due to what the Conservatives have done to our people. I love God, I am not anti Pope. I don't see there's anything wrong with being both. May you have a blessed Advent.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+10 # James 2011-11-30 13:45
Way to go TFP!!! It's pretty sad to see nuns demanding to be priests, no obedience whatsoever and sad to see a woman upset that the 12 apostles were men, she needs to take that up with Jesus not us. It never changes with the feminists does it, just like Eve did to Adam...stay home woman and take care of your family and give work to the man, the HEAD of household!
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
-20 # Mitch 2011-11-30 14:11
I am disturbed by TFP's continual refusal to use any of the words of Christ or to preach the gospel at all. Jesus loves these people, he wants to bring them into His kingdom. TFP volunteers are sinners just like everyone - yet TFP continues to play up the US vs. THEM mentality to the detriment of their own message and the message of the church. TFP volunteers need to read the Theology of the Body and more work by Benedixt XVI/Joseph Ratzinger. If you continue to push against the other side, they will just push back and the church looks like any other earthly institution. What makes the Church different is that we have a heavenly kingdom and our faith ultimately lies there, which allows us to deal patiently with our brother and sister who live in error. TFP seems obsessed with the ANTI-Socialism message, but not nearly as concerned with Christ's message of complete love and sacrifice. When will the conservative catholics start being more catholic and less conservative?
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
-10 # Mitch 2011-11-30 14:17
Secondly - what ever happened to St. Augustine's Just War Theory? Anyone who has read St. Augustine's work here knows full well that non of the wars we are fighting meets the criteria of a just war. TFP seems to be horribly ignorant of the facts behind these wars and what is actually going on. Our troops are being pawned out in over 150 countries world wide even though the US has no standing declaration of war!!! They are coming home with PTSD and other diseases as broken husbands and fathers all due to stupid wars. Unless our conservatives wake up and break free of the propaganda and rhetoric, our country will fall apart. Vote for Ron Paul 2012.

Editor: Please see:

Just War and the Pacifist Offensive on Sovereignty

http://www.tfpstudentaction.org/politically-incorrect/just-war/just-war-and-the-pacifist-offensive-on-sovereignty.html
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+8 # J 2011-11-30 15:04
Quoting Mitch:
If you continue to push against the other side, they will just push back and the church looks like any other earthly institution. What makes the Church different is that we have a heavenly kingdom and our faith ultimately lies there, which allows us to deal patiently with our brother and sister who live in error.


To rebuke the sinner is a spiritual work of mercy...or would you rather SOA Watch people continue corrupting youth with their error and go to hell for it?

The "Us vs Them" is exactly what the SOA Watch is doing...or maybe you don't like it when traditional orthodox Catholics fight back with TRUTH?

Why doesn't the SOA Watch have anything to say about Communist Cuba and the +100,000 dead in that Marxist-Leninist dictatorshop? What about the tens of thousands of dead at the hands of the Communist FARC in Colombia? The atrocities of the Shining Path in Peru, etc. etc.?
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+12 # Bernard 2011-11-30 15:44
God bless TFP Student Action for doing this and may God bless our troops.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+2 # abby 2011-11-30 16:00
Quoting James:
Way to go TFP!!! It's pretty sad to see nuns demanding to be priests, no obedience whatsoever and sad to see a woman upset that the 12 apostles were men, she needs to take that up with Jesus not us. It never changes with the feminists does it, just like Eve did to Adam...stay home woman and take care of your family and give work to the man, the HEAD of household!

Quoting James:
Way to go TFP!!! It's pretty sad to see nuns demanding to be priests, no obedience whatsoever and sad to see a woman upset that the 12 apostles were men, she needs to take that up with Jesus not us. It never changes with the feminists does it, just like Eve did to Adam...stay home woman and take care of your family and give work to the man, the HEAD of household!

I am confused, are you saying all women are supposed to stay home with the kids while the man does all the work? or was that sarcastic? I'm Catholic (conservative) and was never told that
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+6 # Kathy16670 2011-11-30 16:38
TFP ~ you speak for me! I am grateful for the work you do!
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+4 # John Flaherty 2011-11-30 18:39
Richard C,
If SOA proposes evil, you're welcome to provoke Congressional inquiries into the school's activities. Baring that, you have a MUCH weaker argument.

Mitch,
Keep in mind, people of all stripes have quoted and mis-quoted the Bible at length; we've only heard from former Popes rather rarely. If you see an US v THEM mentality, perhaps you're beginning to acknowledge that it's been there for a loooong time.

I think TFP's efforts quite laudable. They're a group that offers a degree of military discipline without being a military unit, they give young men an outlet for proposing high virtue, and they do so with a classy approach.

While I don't regret going through ROTC, nor my years in the Air Force, I DO wish that a similar sort of group had been about when I was in college.
It's a VERY good thing to give our younger adults something else to think about.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+6 # Dave 2011-11-30 18:40
TFP represents common sense and the dignity of Christian beliefs. Unfortunately the far left are conditioned to follow and not think independently or with any depth. They use liberal chic bumper stickers to express their beliefs, all of which are overly simplistic and without any logical thought. Oppose, oppose, oppose; and protest, protest, protest are all they know. The hundreds I have met of all generations are ungrateful spoiled brats.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+6 # Miles Eggimann 2011-11-30 18:50
What a courageous and beautiful gesture these good young Catholic men are making at Ft. Benning. It gives one hope that such things are still possible for people who take their strength and direction from Heaven. Also delightful is the positive coverage by the local TV station - unexpected, but delightful!
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+7 # Kenyi 2011-11-30 18:53
Good job, Catholics! God bless you.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+7 # Sergio Enriquez 2011-11-30 19:01
I commend the TFP, this kind of courage in young Catholics makes me have much hope for the future for all true Catholics! March forward young men march forward!
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+6 # HELEN MACMINN 2011-11-30 19:14
John, et al, Thank you so very much for your courageous stand for our troops and our country. You guys are the best!!! Love ya, Helen
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
-7 # scragsma 2011-11-30 23:36
Quoting Mitch:
I am disturbed by TFP's continual refusal to use any of the words of Christ or to preach the gospel at all. Jesus loves these people, he wants to bring them into His kingdom. TFP continues to play up the US vs. THEM mentality to the detriment of their own message and the message of the church. TFP volunteers need to read the Theology of the Body and more work by Benedixt XVI/Joseph Ratzinger.


But the TFP guys ARE teaching Christ's message, in order to bring the people God loves into His kingdom. That's their purpose. There isn't any "us vs them" mentality, only presenting the Truth. I have no doubt they've all studied Theology of the Body and J Ratzinger's writings thoroughly.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+4 # ralph 2011-12-01 14:41
It's so sad that we have so many educated but equally ignorant people. Keep up the good work TFP.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+2 # Andrew 2011-12-02 12:45
Great Work! We will keep you in our prayers. May the Holy Spirit be with you.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+3 # Guy Joseph 2011-12-02 14:02
It is encouraging to know that losers who follow the excommunicated priest Fr. Roy Bourgeois are losing patience, and sence of direction. If the devil directs them, what can you expect?
God Who stands for Goodness will always win at the end. We only have to pray, set good examples, and be patient.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+5 # Guy Joseph 2011-12-02 14:05
It is sad to know that satan has followers even among those whose hands have been consecrated to the service of God. We must pray that the excommunicated Priest Fr. Roy Bourgeois returns to his faith, as Saul
who became St. Paul did.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
-1 # Guy Joseph 2011-12-02 14:12
Quoting Jeannon Kralj:
Can't say I am fully FOR either side in this dialectical display.

You have socialist Catholics of the communist variety vying against socialist Catholics of the NAZI (National Socialists - fascist) kind.

There are dark forces behind the scenes loving what they have engineered here.

Each should demonstrate separately for the love Christ, to uplift the Savior, to risk being arrested and jailed for the Christ. Demonstrate not against this evil City of Man, but for the City of God.

REPLY:
When you are dealing with Catholic Religion and God, you cannot sit on the fence. You are either for what our Church teaches and stands for, OR against everything. There is NO other place to stand. So, make up your mind, before it is too late.
Guy Joseph
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+2 # Guy Joseph 2011-12-02 14:19
May God shower His Blessings abundantly on those who stand for His Cause. Well done TFP. Our prayers are with you in these bad times, and in all the hatred, slander, disgrace, and shame you have to face and all trouble you are going through for taking this stand for us.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+1 # Marie Czarnecki 2011-12-03 16:00
GOD BLESS YOU ALL!!!!!!
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # Jack Tidwell 2011-12-13 06:44
Quoting Barbara Anna:
Quoting Richard C:
If TFP supports evils such as SOA then they are as bad as the atheist/socialist protestors.
If I didn't have strong Catholic values I would probably be a socialist
If I didn't have strong social justice values I would possibly be fascist.

Richard C., did you read this article?


How many of Occupy Fort Benning / SOA Watch have actually toured WHINSEC? If you had you would would be sobered up by the facts and go home enlightened giving thanks that there are those willing to risk their lives for higher values and for peace on earth. Occupiers must remember that the police are there protecting you.... even from some among you who would do you harm. Do yourself and us all a favor if you have come this far... tour WHINSEC and see what it is that you are complaining about.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # Tout 2011-12-18 20:58
Stay away from Socialism, if you want to be a good Christian. Stay away from Socialism.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 

Add comment

Comments will be approved by a moderator before appearing on the site. Any comments that contain inappropriate language or content will not be posted. Your email is required but will not be made public.


Security code
Refresh

Stand with the Scouts

Boy Scouts STAND with us